<p>1. They haven't said. I guess we're supposed to assume McAllister was a member in his youth. </p><p>2. Perhaps the mispelled beginning of McAllister </p><p>3. RJ claimed he was a real psyhic. </p><p>4. He must be really good in bed is all I can think of. </p>

<p>3.I coudn't quite catch where McAllister explicitly claims that he's a real psychic. That was a trick, one we'll never know, like Jane. </p><p>4.In a way similar to how he managed to enslave Bob Kirkland's brother. Remember he raped and killed Lorelei's sister. So we can assume, given the general description of his abilities, he managed to prise several personal details from Lorelei's sister. Details he would used to turn Lorelei. </p>

<p>I'd like add another unanswered question: </p><p>5. Why McAllister look terrified and unwilling to admit he's Red John when Jane saw the tattoo in his left shoulder, since RJ was always narcisistic? </p><p>(Like: "Oh, let me wait 2 weeks before telling him I'm Red John. Let do some explosion, fake my death, go to a church and maybe I found Jane, so I could finally tell I'm Red John and kill him, instead of bombing all over this house and get laid the next 2 weeks.") </p>

<p>2. Anything they come up to explain that will be inconceivable, since no one dying would be worried about pronouns ("he") and stative verbs ("is"). If you're bleeding to die, you probably would use your energy to write down just "marshall" or "macallister". </p>

<p>6. Has anyone ever heard anything so awkwardly, comically fake as the infamous "Red John Voice" coming out of McAllister's mouth? That line sounded like it was recorded in a garage studio 500 miles away from the church.  Were we meant to believe TM actually made that noise in front of Jane? </p><p>PJ: So I'm supposed to die, am I? After all these years, it seems kind of unfair. </p><p>TM: (inhales helium) Totally fair. Game's over and I won. </p><p>PJ: It's not a game. </p><p>TM: (swallows gravel & rusty nails) There's a winner and a loser -- It's a game. </p><p>This game should be thrown out and re-played. </p>

<div class="quote"><i>Quote:
I'd like add another unanswered question: <p>5. Why McAllister look terrified and unwilling to admit he's Red John when Jane saw the tattoo in his left shoulder, since RJ was always narcisistic? </p><p>(Like: "Oh, let me wait 2 weeks before telling him I'm Red John. Let do some explosion, fake my death, go to a church and maybe I found Jane, so I could finally tell I'm Red John and kill him, instead of bombing all over this house and get laid the next 2 weeks.") </p> </i></div>
<p>That would be because he's terrified that Jane might win after all. Remember he saved Jane on the church roof in Napa which Jane acknowledged to Lisbon. He was expecting that he'd managed to draw Jane's alliance even partially. And Jane, in inviting him to his house, said he needed his help in unmasking Red John (Bertram - Jane said he was keeping his promise that Bertram would be on the scene when Red John was captured; Smith - Jane bullied; Haffner - Lisbon was sent to sweet talk him; Stiles - Jane used his obsession with protecting his cult, that if Stiles presented himself, he'd leave Stiles in peace to build his legacy). That's why McAllister was shocked at the complete turn of situation - he's been taken for a ride. </p><p>Moreover this is the first John-Jane face-off where Jane is in complete control and John's a sitting duck. It went against his vanity and narcissism that the tale should end so. That was why he was afraid. </p>