Sheriff Mcallister is not Red John!

This post is locked.

Redjohnhaffner·11/26/2013 in Red John Theories

I personally do not think McAllister is Red John. It is too easy, and we are just mid-season. The clues don't exactly point to him. "RJ" is barely seen in the whole series, he is seen in the very beginning and almost never again.

I would other people's comments/theories what have you =D

(Edited by administrators)

Red John

A Fandom user·12/1/2013

McAllister was Red John!

Pretty good one I would sayit. I think the end was also extraordinary. If you think too much you cannot see the reality.

(Edited by A Fandom user)

A Fandom user·12/22/2013

It's Partidge.

He faked his death.

Fact

(Edited by A Fandom user)

A Fandom user·12/22/2013

I was just dissapointed that he begged for his life. I dont believe Red John would do that. I expected him to accept it or at least know that Jane had planted the gun. After all these years of being one step ahead he seemed to be caught and killed too easliy.

(Edited by A Fandom user)

A Fandom user·12/23/2013

Hello! If you're a fan of The Mentalist vote for Best Procedural TV show in 2013. Let us help you achieve the Seson 7! Vote!

http://www.tv.com/features/best-of-2013/vote/poll/SpecialFeatures:list:best-proceduarl-2013

(Edited by A Fandom user)

A Fandom user·3/20/2014

Quote:
Guys, McAllister is Red John and he is a damn good one at that... The actor did a terrific job and it makes perfect sense that your ultimate villian of the series is not a character that is prominently seen, like Bertram, who would make the audience suspect that they are Red John.

At last, a sane person on here...

(Edited by A Fandom user)

A Fandom user·5/21/2014

PresidentCrypto145 wrote:
Sorry, but you have to accept it, McAllister was Red John, perhaps it wasn't the reveal that all of us were expecting, but at the end, Heller himself said once : when the fans discover who is Red John, they will be dissapointed i guess that at the end, Heller and the whole CBS team gave us what they promised: a genius criminal mastermind behind a mask of a pathetic, sad, lonely and Ugly man: Sheriff Thomas McAllister ... :-) .....Hey Xander Berkeley is not ugly !

(Edited by A Fandom user)

A Fandom user·5/26/2014

are they even going to be doing a season 7 !?

(Edited by A Fandom user)

A Fandom user·6/6/2014

In an interview with the writers of the show, they vigorously claimed the death of Red John. http://www.zap2it.com/blogs/the_mentalist_after_red_john_then_what_simon_baker_creator_bruno_heller_tease_janes_future-2013-11

Here you will find their strategy to stray off the idea of Red John as they would like to instill the gravity and real-ness of the death of the main antagonist.

Given that the seventh installment of the series might be their last, ergo the conclusion of the series and all of its story, I believe that Red John is truly dead, may it be McAllister or a n unknown man who has been dead all along only to be revived by McAllister.

Nevertheless, the story might divuldge in the dismantling of Blake Association with plot twists.

(Edited by A Fandom user)

Adam Up Bxtch·7/22/2014

I personally still think Partridge is Red John......... his voice sounded very much like Red John's over the phone and that whole voice changing bullshit with McAllister was just plain crap, McAllister being Red John is a very disappointing ending.....McAllister doesn't even strike me as the Serial Killer type. Although i feel Red John's presence on the show is anything but done.....

(Edited by Adam Up Bxtch)

BattleshipMan·7/26/2014

Dammit, what the hell do you think this is, some kind of ridicious debate? Red John story is over and that McAllister was Red John. Get that through your heads and move on.

(Edited by BattleshipMan)